View stories by State
HOME RSS FEEDS ARCHIVES ABOUT US SITE MAP PUBLICATIONS
Search using      Advanced
Friday, July 30, 2010
or Browse All States
CRIME & COURTS
ECONOMY & BUSINESS
EDUCATION
ELECTIONS
ENERGY
ENVIRONMENT
GOVS' SPEECHES
HEALTH CARE
HOMELAND SECURITY
POLITICS
RECESSION & RECOVERY
SOCIAL POLICY
TAXES & BUDGET
TECHNOLOGY
TRANSPORTATION
ARCHIVES
COMMENTARIES
PUBLICATIONS
RSS FEEDS
STATE SPEECHES
NEWS ALERTS
PUBLIC POLICY LINKS
TOOLBARS
STATE BLOGS
ISSUE BLOGS


Tuesday, February 02, 2010

Va. Senate bans health insurance mandate

Comments Write the editor Print this story

The Democratic-led Virginia Senate sent a strong message about health care reform efforts in Washington, D.C., on Monday (Feb. 1), passing a bill that makes it illegal for Virginians to be required to buy health insurance.

With Republicans in control of the state’s House of Delegates and governor’s mansion, the bill could become law, The Washington Post reported. The effort would throw another wrench into congressional Democrats’ plans to revamp the nation’s health care system in the wake of a special election in Massachusetts that stripped the party of its 60-vote, filibuster-proof majority in the U.S. Senate.

An “individual mandate” that requires Americans to buy health insurance is a centerpiece of federal health care legislation. Virginia’s move could suggest that President Obama — who reiterated his support for reform during his State of the Union address last week — “is failing to reassure members of his own party that current reform efforts remain worthwhile,” The Post said.

A groundswell of opposition to the federal effort is emerging in statehouses around the country, The Associated Press reported today. Bills similar to the legislation cleared by the Virginia Senate are being considered in 35 states, with some lawmakers seeking constitutional amendments to prohibit mandatory health insurance. An Idaho legislative committee has approved a bill similar to Virginia’s, and in Missouri, an overflow crowd showed up at a hearing room when that state’s constitutional amendment was being debated, the AP reported.

What is notable about Monday’s action in the Virginia Senate, however, is that Democrats joined the effort, which has been led by conservatives in most states. Five Democrats joined all 18 Republicans in opposition to a health care mandate. The votes “suggest that Democrats on the state level fear that supporting health care reform could be politically damaging,” The Post said.

“Today’s Take” provides a quick analysis of the day’s top news in state government.



Comment on this story in the space below by registering with Stateline.org.

COMMENTS (6)
Most Recent Comments
Virginia Ban on paying health care
By Jake Sullivan on Feb 11, 2010 8:56:08 PM

This is absolutely the definition of States Rights, I.E. the 10th Amendment. I have heard from too many shows on TV that this could be overturned by a federal mandate. HOW is this not on ALL TV channels as the biggest killer of the federal health care bill? I did not know that states were passing this till VA did. This is huge, for the fed to override states rights is huge. That breaks the contract of the Union? Right?

Report as Offensive
Car Insurance vs Health Insurance
By Kyle Lang on Feb 2, 2010 1:53:56 PM

Nobody is forcing you to drive. If you don't own a car you don't need to purchase it.

Report as Offensive
More tax dollars down the drain
By Nicole Miller on Feb 2, 2010 11:57:09 AM

Just great. Not it is a law that my tax dollars have to go to people who refuse to help themselves. Not to mention what this will do my health care costs as doctors and hospitals raise their prices to offset the people who choose not to carry their own insurance. This state requires all of its drivers to have auto insurace in order to register your car, how is this any different that requiring people to get health insurance?

Report as Offensive
Illegal Mandate from D.C.--Not For Me!
By Barry Shook on Feb 2, 2010 10:44:22 AM

It is illegal for the American Government to tell it's citizen's that if they are not covered already, then they must buy health insurance. I have, and pay for my own health insurance, because I know what happens if you don't have it when you need it. IF THEY TELL US WE HAVE TO HAVE HEALTH INSURANCE, ARE THEY GOING TO TELL US WHO WE HAVE TO BUY IT FROM? Whichever insurance company that owns the most votes in the House and Senate will make sure of that!

Report as Offensive
Doctors are required ... (but not legislators, apparently)
By Paul Perspectoff on Feb 2, 2010 10:00:42 AM

So when is Virginia going to require people to pay for their health care, then?

Doctors are required to provide emergency care no matter whether the patient pays or not. Doctors subsidize much of this country's health care themselves.

I know. I've gone bankrupt twice providing emergency care at ERs (I no longer do).

The problem is that everyone wants things for free and because physicians in general are more altruistic and have a stronger moral code, they take care of people even to the point of going bankrupt themselves. A certain proportion of America is happy to let that happen (clearly so in Virgina).

Our politicians have no such code, apparently.

Instead of crafting a system where everyone gets care (instead of just letting physicians shoulder the burden), they destroy the system, prevent rules for everyone to be insured, yet leave rules in place (EMTALA, for example) that require physicians to provide free care in emergency rooms.

Boo on the Virigina legislature. This is America at its worst.


Report as Offensive
Read More Comments
Healthcare mandate
By George Hendrickson on Feb 2, 2010 9:38:25 AM

It's good to see the states starting to stand up for their rights. The federal government has become out of control. This is America, not Europe or Venezeula...

Report as Offensive
Recent stories from Stateline.org
Or click here to visit our archives

The Pew Charitable Trusts applies the power of knowledge to solve today’s most challenging problems. Pew's Center on the States identifies and advances state policy solutions.